← All insights

Article

Fewer Pairs, Higher Stakes

Two blank cards pinned to a wall among empty pin holes, with a stack of cards on the desk below

U.S. shoe shoppers are buying fewer pairs and paying more for each one. Retailers are holding less inventory than they did before 2020. Put those two facts together and every style in next season’s line has a harder job than it did a few years ago.

It has to earn its place. And the moment that matters is the decision point, before a style gets locked into the product lifecycle management (PLM) system and development starts.

For a long time, a footwear line could carry a few maybes. A style that underperformed got absorbed by a big season’s volume. If it sat, a markdown cleared it and the team moved on. That room is closing from three sides at once, and it starts with the shopper.

This summer, AlixPartners and FDRA (Footwear Distributors and Retailers of America) surveyed 1,000 U.S. footwear consumers. Of those, 39 percent said they’d cut back on pairs before switching to cheaper brands.

That’s a shopper who is staying loyal and getting pickier. They aren’t trading down. They’re deciding which pair doesn’t make it home.

For a product team, that changes the question. It’s no longer whether a style will sell some pairs. It’s whether it’s the pair they keep.

The same survey shows what earns the spend. On what drives spending more, 41 percent pointed to superior comfort or fit, and 39 percent to durability, a shoe built to last.

You can’t add comfort, fit or durability to a shoe at launch. They’re settled early, when the team sets the fit, picks the materials and chooses how the shoe gets made.

The sales data tells the same story from the other side of the counter. Circana’s read on the first half of 2026 is that U.S. footwear sales rose 1 percent compared with the same period last year. Higher average selling prices kept making up for weaker demand, which showed up as fewer pairs sold.

For the full year, Circana expects sales to come in relatively flat, with higher prices continuing to make up for lower unit demand.

Dollars holding. Pairs down. When fewer pairs bring in the same dollars or more, each one carries more of the P&L. A weak style can’t hide in volume anymore. There’s less volume to hide in.

The stores those pairs sell through have less room to carry a miss, too. The U.S. Census Bureau tracks how much inventory stores carry relative to their sales. For clothing and clothing accessory stores, a category that includes shoe stores, that ratio was 2.11 in July 2026. It was 2.30 in July 2024 and 2.39 in July 2019.

In plain terms, stores are holding less stock against what they sell. That leaves less room on the wall, and less patience, for a style that doesn’t move.

When a style doesn’t move now, the cost shows up quickly. Shoe Station Group, the retailer formerly known as Shoe Carnival, described this plainly in its second-quarter results. Net sales were $284.3 million, compared with $306.4 million in the second quarter of 2025. The company said the quarter was affected by assortments that didn’t fully match the customers shopping its stores. It sped up clearing out aged and excess inventory, and that put pressure on its gross profit margin.

I respect a company that names it that clearly. And the pattern isn’t unique to one retailer. When the assortment and the shopper drift apart, the cleanup is a markdown, and the markdown comes out of margin.

It all goes back to one call: whether to go to prototype or pass. That’s the critical product decision point, and the right time to make it is before the style goes into the brand’s PLM system. Once it’s in the system, it sets work in motion: samples to build, materials to order, and merchandising, marketing and launch plans that take months. From there, every change gets harder and more expensive, and cutting the style gets personal. Before then, it’s a short conversation. Nobody has to defend a sample that doesn’t exist yet.

None of this means running fewer SKUs to be efficient. A smaller line can still be full of the wrong styles. The point is which styles get built at all. Each one needs a reason to exist that a shopper buying fewer pairs would agree with.

That standard can start at your next kickoff. Before any style moves into development, have it answer three things in writing:

  1. Who it’s for, and which pair it replaces in their closet.
  2. The evidence on comfort, fit and durability that says this one earns the spend.
  3. The one thing that would take it out of the line, and when the team will find out.

If a style can’t answer those at the decision point, it won’t answer them at line review either. It will just be harder to let go.

Fewer pairs means higher stakes on every one. The lines that hold up next season will be the ones where every style was there on purpose.

Tell me how your team decides what makes the cut.

With research from AlixPartners, Footwear Distributors & Retailers of America (FDRA), Circana and U.S. Census Bureau.

Originally published on LinkedIn.

← All insights

Get a demo.