← All insights

Article

Your Returns Already Know What to Fix

A brown paper mailer on a wooden worktable, with pattern paper, a tape measure and fabric swatches behind it

Every season, brands pay to process the same fit mistake. A shopper sends something back, the return gets handled and the file closes. What it said about fit rarely reaches the people deciding the next line.

That matters because fit is a product decision, made months before launch, when the team approves the pattern, the size run and the sample. A fit return is feedback on that decision. It just arrives after everyone has moved on.

Around 70 percent. That’s how many shoppers in a Coresight Research survey said size or fit was why they sent apparel back. The survey covered 212 U.S. adults who had returned apparel bought online in the last 12 months, part of a May 2026 report sponsored by Alvanon, a sizing and fit company. The same report puts the average U.S. online apparel return rate at 23.4 percent in 2025. Fit isn’t a side issue in returns. It’s the main one.

Picture two hypothetical styles. A knit top is cut tight through the shoulders, and a running shoe runs a half size short that the wear test didn’t catch. Both come back for size, and both get processed. If nobody walks those reasons back to the person who set the spec, the next line starts with the same call.

That makes it sound like a design miss, and sometimes it is. But there’s no shared size to design against. In footwear, every brand builds on its own base lasts, so each brand ends up with its own size system. Say a shopper wears a men’s 9 at one brand. At another, the same foot might need an 8.5, and at a third a 9.5. Men’s and women’s lasts differ, and construction runs tighter or looser by brand. That makes a brand’s own size system the only definition of fit its customers get, and keeping it consistent is a product job.

Online, shoppers can’t try anything on first, so they hedge. Someone new to a brand orders the same shoe in two or three sizes, or a sweater in a medium and a large, keeps the one that fits and sends the rest back. In the NRF and Happy Returns’ 2025 returns report, merchants said nearly one in four purchases in the last year included a bracketed item, rising to 26 percent in apparel and footwear. Those returns aren’t all fit mistakes. But the size a shopper keeps is the most honest read on how a style really runs. If people who usually wear an 11 keep the 11.5, the shoe runs small.

The same report estimates that shoppers would send back $849.9 billion in merchandise across U.S. retail in 2025, or 15.8 percent of sales. Money on that scale gets an owner, a budget and a process, and the process is getting stricter. It also found that 72 percent of merchants had started charging for at least one return option in the past 12 months. Shoppers notice. Among the consumers surveyed, 57 percent said they had decided not to shop with a retailer after it started charging for returns. Picture a runner who has to pay to send back a pair that didn’t fit. That runner remembers the brand. A stricter policy can cut returns. It can’t fix the fit.

Radial, a third-party logistics provider, and Two Boxes, which sells returns technology, surveyed 200 retailers across six industries in July 2025. Among goals for working with a logistics partner, reducing the cost of processing returns came first, at 59 percent. Improving visibility, data and reporting on returns came last of seven, at 25 percent. Cost has an owner. What a return says about fit is still looking for one.

That signal belongs in a product conversation, because the companies that process returns aren’t set up to read it. The size run, the stretch in the fabric, the fit through the forefoot of a shoe. Those all get settled at the decision point, before a style is locked in and enters the product lifecycle management (PLM) system. After that, changing them means new samples, new material orders and a launch plan that has to move. Before that, it’s a conversation around a table.

The fix can start small, with the next line, and it doesn’t take solving sizing for the whole industry. Before the team commits, read what returns on the closest existing styles say about fit, including which size shoppers kept when they ordered more than one. Put that in front of the designer, the developer and the product line manager while the spec is still open, and give one person the job of carrying it into that room.

Brands will always process returns. The real cost is paying for the same fit mistake twice, and that gets settled before a style is locked in.

I’d like to hear where fit feedback stops on your team, and who could carry it the rest of the way.

With research from Coresight Research, National Retail Federation and Radial.

Originally published on LinkedIn.

← All insights

Get a demo.